From Reviews to Reputation: How Online Comments Shape Consumer Trust

Key Findings

Online comments have become a formidable force in shaping a company's reputation, thanks to their immediacy, authenticity, and engagement potential. Unlike static reviews, comments spread instantly across social media and news platforms, shifting public perception almost overnight.

Here are examples of conversations that puts a brand’s reputation at risk, or raises potential risks:

• Allegations of Shopee’s questionable tactics against sellers surfaced on Reddit, triggering a wave of comments. Some users called for a switch to rival e-commerce platforms, amplifying the backlash.
• Even conversations about cooking tips can open up spaces for customers to promote rivals like Ramlee in this example, where an Ayamas' customer complained about the difficulties in cooking the frozen chicken.
• Singapore’s DBS Bank faced intense scrutiny on LinkedIn, where users repeatedly urged others to switch to Wise due to concerns over unclear bank transfer fees. The post was soon flooded with finance companies promoting their own services as alternatives to DBS.
• "Review bombing" is a growing phenomenon typically occurring in the gaming and movie industries, but it can also affect businesses like this one where a small enterprise owner sought help after being reviewed bombed by disgruntled non-customers. 

‍

Who It Affects

Brands that need to engage consumers on social media channels are most impacted, particularly if their reputation relies on word-of-mouth style recommendations. These industries rely on online reviews not just for credibility but also for customer acquisition and retention. These are some examples:

E-commerce and Retail: Online Marketplaces (Amazon, Shopee, Lazada)

• Reviews significantly influence purchase decisions, especially for products that can't be tested beforehand.

Financial Services: Banks and Digital Payment Platforms (Trustpilot, Google Reviews), Insurance Companies (BBB, Trustpilot)

• Consumers rely on reviews to assess reliability, customer support, and fees.

Beauty and Personal Care: Cosmetics and Skincare Brands (Sephora, YouTube Influencers), Hair and Nail Salons (Google, Facebook Reviews)

• Customers trust peer reviews to evaluate product effectiveness and service quality.

Hospitality and Travel: Hotels and Resorts (TripAdvisor, Google Reviews), Airlines and Travel Agencies (Skyscanner, Expedia) Restaurants and Cafés (Yelp, Zomato, Google Reviews)

• Consumers trust reviews for service quality, cleanliness, and overall experience before booking.

Healthcare and Wellness:  Cosmetic Surgery Clinics, Fitness and Wellness Centers (Gyms, Spas, Yoga Studios)

• Patients rely on reviews to choose healthcare providers and treatment centers.

‍

Why It Matters

Misinformation can severely impact consumer trust, brand reputation, and financial performance. Consumers tend to trust customer feedback more than advertisements, and they are more likely to believe personal recommendations over corporate press statements.

Reddit, a community-driven platform known for its authentic and unfiltered discussions, thrives on anonymity and democratic engagement through upvotes. While it fosters deep conversations on niche topics, it can also be a breeding ground for misinformation.

In contrast, LinkedIn is a professional networking platform where users present polished, career-focused content. Its reliance on real names lends it credibility, but it often leans toward corporate jargon and self-promotion.

The key takeaway? No matter which platform an issue arises on, your brand’s ability to steer the conversation away from fake comments and misinformation is crucial to maintaining a strong reputation.

‍

Trends and Developments

Uncontrolled online chatter can rapidly disseminate false narratives, leading to real-world consequences such as revenue losses and internal conflicts. Search engines and social media algorithms amplify trending comments, increasing their visibility and potential for damage.

Other trends include:

• Competitors leveraging negative comments to promote alternative services.
• Malicious actors spreading negative reviews and damaging brand reputation.
• Fake positive reviews backfiring, leading to consumer distrust and regulatory penalties.
• Companies manipulating reviews, damaging long-term credibility.
• Online comments wielding more influence than traditional marketing

‍

What We Anticipate and Opportunities

Faqcheck is an expert in monitoring trends like this across online communities. Spiralling chatter, and online reviews—whether boosting or damaging a company’s reputation—can have serious consequences for businesses, consumers, and digital platforms.

Fake reviews distort consumer decisions and customer experiences. Companies must actively monitor and combat content fraud while maintaining transparency.

Opportunities include:

• Developing robust crisis communication strategies to counter misinformation.
• Investing in AI detection tools to identify and mitigate fake content.
• Engaging proactively with the media to prevent misinformation from taking root.
• Actively managing and engaging with online comments to protect brand image.

‍